The film has a great beginning, an okay middle and a stupid ending.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

The film has a great beginning, an okay middle and a stupid ending.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

It's unclear whether we're supposed to be laughing at, or with, the protagonists - a fatal mistake.

~ Keith Hennessey Brown -

It's unclear whether we're supposed to be laughing at, or with, the protagonists - a fatal mistake.

~ Keith Hennessey Brown -

The fat-is-gross non-PC running gag trips up after half an hour.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

Hornby's novel is a master class in relationships and rich human interaction and the Farellys have done it reasonable justice, however diluted by its screenwriters.

~ Scott Macdonald -

It disappoints on two fronts. The directors, Bobby and Peter Farrelly, love vulgar so much they can't be anything else and the complexity of the human body is too wondrous for a bunch of animators to figure out.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

It disappoints on two fronts. The directors, Bobby and Peter Farrelly, love vulgar so much they can't be anything else and the complexity of the human body is too wondrous for a bunch of animators to figure out.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

The film is patchy. The funny parts are inspired. Others... fall flat.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

The film is patchy. The funny parts are inspired. Others... fall flat.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

This film sees the brothers right back on form but ringing a few changes and even making the odd serious point.

~ Jeff Robson -

This film sees the brothers right back on form but ringing a few changes and even making the odd serious point.

~ Jeff Robson -

If the plot is poor, the direction takes dull to new levels of blandness.

~ Amber Wilkinson -

If the plot is poor, the direction takes dull to new levels of blandness.

~ Amber Wilkinson -

Mortensen has gained weight. He plays Tony with confidence.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -

Mortensen has gained weight. He plays Tony with confidence.

~ Angus Wolfe Murray -